Loans Plainly

Guide (educational)

Cancel private mortgage insurance

Learn what private mortgage insurance protects, when you can ask to cancel it, when it must end automatically, and which loans follow a different rule.

What you are paying for

The CFPB says PMI is insurance the lender arranges with a private insurer. It covers the lender's loss if you stop paying. The usual trigger at purchase is a conventional loan with a down payment below 20 percent of the price. The same idea applies when you refinance a conventional loan and your equity is below 20 percent of the home's value.

The premium is often monthly and added to the mortgage payment. It shows on the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure in the projected-payments section. Sometimes the premium is a single upfront amount in the closing costs. Sometimes it is both. An upfront premium may not be refunded if you move or refinance. A monthly premium is the one cancellation can stop going forward. Read which kind you have before you expect a check back.

How to read a loan disclosure is where the projected payment and the closing-cost lines are explained in general. This page is only the mortgage-insurance line.

A higher interest rate can be offered instead of PMI. The CFPB says that tradeoff can cost more or less than PMI depending on how long you keep the loan. Taxes are a question for a tax adviser, not for this guide. Saving to a 20 percent down payment can avoid PMI on a conventional purchase and can also come with a lower rate. Those are purchase decisions. If the loan is already open, the rest of this page is the cancellation decision.

The date you can ask

For the loans this CFPB explanation covers, you may ask the servicer to cancel PMI on the date the principal balance is scheduled to fall to 80 percent of the home's original value. That first date should be on the PMI disclosure you received with the mortgage. If you cannot find it, ask the servicer.

Extra payments that bring the balance to 80 percent of original value let you ask before the scheduled date. How extra payments affect interest explains principal payments in general. On this loan, the extra payment matters only if the servicer applies it to principal and the balance used for the test actually falls. Check the next statement. Do not count a payment that was held as a future installment.

Original value is generally the lower of the contract price and the appraisal at purchase. If you refinanced, original value is the appraisal at the refinance. Later market increases do not rewrite that number for this test. If the home is worth more and you want a cancellation based on current value, you are in a different request, often an investor's own guideline. The CFPB says investors such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac can have their own cancellation guidelines, and that those guidelines cannot be less favorable than the legal baseline above. Ask which guideline the servicer is using. Do not assume a neighbor's appraisal story is your rule.

The servicer must grant a timely written request if you meet the CFPB's criteria:

  • The request is in writing.
  • You have a good payment history and you are current.
  • You can certify that there is no junior lien, such as a second mortgage.
  • You can show, if asked, that the property value has not dropped below the original value. If it has, cancellation on this schedule may be refused.

A HELOC or home equity loan behind the first mortgage is a junior lien. Home equity loan versus HELOC explains that second claim. It can be the reason a PMI request fails even when the first-mortgage balance looks low enough. Payoff or release of that junior lien is a separate file.

The dates that do not require a request

Even if you never ask, the CFPB says the servicer generally must terminate PMI on the date the balance is scheduled to reach 78 percent of original value, if you are current. If you are behind, termination waits until shortly after the payments are brought current.

There is a second automatic end. The servicer must end PMI the month after you reach the midpoint of the original amortization schedule, if you are current, even when the balance has not reached 78 percent. On a 30-year loan, the midpoint is after 15 years. The CFPB says this midpoint rule is more likely to matter when the loan had an interest-only period, principal forbearance, or a balloon, because those structures can leave the balance higher at the halfway mark. Interest-only periods and balloon payments are the product pages. You still have to be current for the termination to occur.

A worked request

Hypothetical. You bought for $300,000 with an appraisal of $300,000, so original value is $300,000. Eighty percent is $240,000. Seventy-eight percent is $234,000. The PMI disclosure lists a request date when the scheduled balance reaches $240,000. You made extra principal payments and the statement now shows $239,500. You are current. There is no second mortgage.

The request is a letter, not a phone call: your name, the loan number, the property address, a statement that you are requesting PMI cancellation, the balance on the statement, and a copy of that statement. Ask what evidence of value they require and where to send the letter. Keep proof of delivery. If they order an appraisal and the value is below $300,000, the CFPB says you may not be able to cancel on this schedule. That result is about the original-value test, not about whether you have been a good customer in a general sense.

If instead the balance is $250,000 and you are only hoping the home's market value makes the loan-to-value ratio look smaller, this 80 percent test has not been met. Ask whether an investor guideline allows a current-value cancellation. Get the answer in writing, including who pays for an appraisal.

Put the worked numbers on one line

Hypothetical cancellation figures on a $300,000 original value
TestBalanceWhat has to be true
Written request$240,000, which is 80 percentWritten request, current, good payment history, no junior lien, and value not below the original value.
Automatic termination$234,000, which is 78 percent, on the scheduled dateYou are current. If you are not, it waits until shortly after you catch up.
Midpoint of a 30-year termWhatever the balance is after 15 yearsYou are current. The CFPB says this date matters more when an interest-only period, principal forbearance, or a balloon left the balance above 78 percent.

Hypothetical midpoint. Original value is still $300,000, so 78 percent is still $234,000. Because the loan had an interest-only period, the balance after 15 years is $250,000. The 78 percent date has not arrived. The midpoint date has. If you are current, the CFPB says PMI must end the month after that midpoint even though the balance is above $234,000. If you are not current, catch up first. This example is the structure, not a prediction for a loan with different dates.

Read the servicer's answer

A yes should say the date the premium stops. Check the following statement for that line, and also check whether taxes or hazard insurance changed the escrow at the same time. A canceled premium does not freeze the rest of the payment.

A no should say which condition failed. Useful answers name one of these: the request was not in writing, the loan is not yet at the scheduled 80 percent date and extra payments have not brought it there, the account is not current, a junior lien is still on the home, the value evidence shows a decline below original value, or this loan is not the kind of mortgage the cancellation rule covers. "We need an appraisal" is a request for the value evidence the CFPB describes. Ask who orders it, who pays, and what original value they are using. A refusal that does not name a condition is not finished. Ask again, in writing.

When the payment changes for a different reason

A mortgage payment can rise because of taxes, hazard insurance, or escrow, while PMI stays in place. Why a payment increased is the worksheet for separating those lines. Canceling PMI removes one line. It does not freeze taxes or the note rate. If the payment rose and PMI is not the line that changed, a cancellation letter will not explain the bill.

Refinancing can remove PMI by replacing the loan, and it can also charge a new premium if the new loan's equity is still under 20 percent. The upfront premium on the old loan may not come back. Read both facts before you refinance only to "get rid of PMI." Refinancing explained is the cost comparison. This page is the cancellation right on the loan you already have.

What to send

  1. Find the PMI disclosure and the first date it lists.
  2. Confirm the charge is borrower-paid PMI, not lender-paid insurance and not a government program. For FHA or VA mortgage insurance, the CFPB says to ask the servicer, because those requirements differ.
  3. Write the original value and the 80 percent and 78 percent balances.
  4. Match the current principal to those figures, after extra payments have posted.
  5. List any second mortgage or HELOC. If one exists, the certification the CFPB describes is not available until that lien is gone.
  6. Send the cancellation request to the address the servicer gives you for it, and keep proof.
  7. Ask whether an appraisal is required and who pays.
  8. If you are not current, bring the loan current before you expect either the 78 percent termination or the midpoint termination.
  9. Check the following statement to see that the premium stopped, and keep that statement.

Mistakes

Calling the lender's insurance your protection. The CFPB says PMI protects the lender. Foreclosure can still follow a default.

Using today's market value as original value. The cancellation test the CFPB describes uses the purchase figures, or the refinance appraisal, not a later listing price.

Requesting by phone and having no record. The right the CFPB describes is a written request.

Ignoring a junior lien. A HELOC behind the first mortgage can block the certification.

Expecting a refund of an upfront premium. The CFPB says that if you paid upfront and then move or refinance, you might not get that premium back.

Waiting for 78 percent when extra payments already reached 80 percent. You can ask early. The automatic date is the backstop, not the only date.

Limits of this guide

This page does not say that your premium must be canceled, order an appraisal, or cover FHA, VA, or lender-paid insurance. It states the CFPB's description of what PMI is, the written 80 percent request, the 78 percent and midpoint terminations, and the original-value and junior-lien conditions. The PMI disclosure and the servicer's written response are the records for your loan.

When can private mortgage insurance be canceled?
Loans Plainly explains a written request at 80 percent of original value and automatic ending at 78 percent or the loan midpoint.

Where this page fits

Costs, APR, and fees

How interest rate, APR, finance charges, origination fees, and disclosure fields relate to total borrowing cost.

Comparison guides are educational. Loans Plainly does not rank lenders or publish live rates.

Common questions

What is private mortgage insurance?
The CFPB describes PMI as insurance a lender may require on a conventional loan when the down payment is under 20 percent of the purchase price, or when a refinance leaves equity under 20 percent. It protects the lender if you stop paying. It does not stop a foreclosure, and it does not insure you.
When can I ask to cancel PMI?
For many single-family principal-residence mortgages that closed on or after July 29, 1999, you can ask on the date the principal balance is scheduled to reach 80 percent of the home's original value. You can ask sooner if extra payments bring the balance to that point. The request has to be in writing. You generally need a good payment history, current payments, no junior liens, and evidence the value has not fallen below the original value.
When must PMI end even if I do not ask?
The CFPB says the servicer generally must terminate PMI on the date the balance is scheduled to reach 78 percent of the original value, if you are current. If you are not current, termination waits until shortly after you catch up. PMI must also end the month after you reach the midpoint of the original amortization schedule, if you are current, even if the balance is not yet at 78 percent.
What is original value?
The CFPB says original value generally means the lower of the contract price and the appraised value when you bought the home. If you refinanced, original value means the appraised value at the refinance. Extra appreciation after that date is not the figure this cancellation test uses.
Does this page cover every mortgage insurance charge?
No. The CFPB says FHA and VA loans have different requirements, and that you should ask the servicer if the insurance is one of those. Lender-paid mortgage insurance also follows different rules. This page is about borrower-paid private mortgage insurance on the loans the CFPB's cancellation description covers.

Official sources

Sources and references